Serving Carnegie Hill & Museum Mile
Carnegie Hill Paint & Hardware Store
Your neighborhood Benjamin Moore dealer since 1986, just a short walk from Museum Mile.
Welcome to New York Paint & Hardware, the local paint & hardware store Carnegie Hill has trusted for nearly four decades. From the brownstones along 90th Street to the elegant co-ops near Park Avenue, we are the shop your neighbors call when a project needs the right color, the right finish, and honest advice.
Paint & Hardware Expertise for Carnegie Hill’s Historic Interiors
Carnegie Hill is a place where prewar mansions, landmarked townhouses, and refined co-ops set a high standard, and the people who care for them, designers, decorators, building supers, and longtime residents, expect the same from their paint store. Since 1986 our staff has helped match the deep plaster tones and crown-molding whites that historic district interiors call for, recommending premium Benjamin Moore lines like Aura and Regal Select for rooms that deserve to last. We know the difference an exact color match makes in a parlor with original detail, and we take the time to get it right.
- Authorized Benjamin Moore dealer & expert color matching
- 700+ everyday hardware, paint & home essentials
- Free same-day delivery across Manhattan on orders over $100
- In-store pickup at 1668 1st Ave
Benjamin Moore Dealer
The full Benjamin Moore line plus precise in-store color matching.
Fast Local Delivery
Free same-day delivery to Carnegie Hill on orders over $100.
Since 1986
Decades of neighborhood know-how and friendly, expert advice.
Free Same-Day Delivery to Carnegie Hill
Carrying gallons up a walk-up or coordinating a decorator’s order for a Fifth Avenue apartment is the last thing anyone wants to worry about. Place an order over $100 and we deliver the same day, straight to your door near Museum Mile or anywhere in the neighborhood, so your project keeps moving and your color stays true.
Visit or Reach Us
Stop by New York Paint & Hardware at 1668 1st Ave, New York, NY 10128, call 212-249-1614, or use the form below.
We also serve these nearby neighborhoods: Upper East Side, Yorkville, and Lenox Hill.
Carnegie Hill Hardware & Paint FAQ
Is there a hardware store in Carnegie Hill?
Yes. New York Paint & Hardware is at 1668 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10128, a short walk from Museum Mile, and has served Carnegie Hill since 1986. Call 212-249-1614.
Do you deliver paint and hardware to Carnegie Hill?
Yes. Orders over $100 are delivered free the same day to Carnegie Hill and anywhere in Manhattan. In-store pickup is also available at 1668 1st Ave.
Where can I buy Benjamin Moore paint in Carnegie Hill?
New York Paint & Hardware is an authorized Benjamin Moore dealer carrying the full line, including premium lines like Aura and Regal Select, with precise in-store color matching.
Can you match paint colors for a landmarked or prewar Carnegie Hill apartment?
Yes. Our staff has matched deep plaster tones and crown-molding whites for historic district interiors since 1986, and we take the time to get an exact match.
Our services: Custom-Mixed Benjamin Moore Paint & Color Matching, Window Screen Repair & Rescreening, Lamp Repair & Rewiring, Knife & Scissor Sharpening, Key Duplication & High-Security Keys, Lumber & Wood Cutting, Tool Rental, Equipment Rental, Carpet & Upholstery Cleaner Rental.
Questions? Send Us a Message
Tell us what you need and we’ll get right back to you.